Transcript 0:01 [singing] Que pasa, mufasa? Welcome to the Mycopreneur Podcast. 0:16 This is a podcast about people solving problems with mushrooms. I'm your host, Dennis Walker. Let's get down to business. [singing] Que pasa, mufasa? Jeff Chilton, founder and president of Nammex. 0:34 What an honor to host you on the Mycopreneur Podcast. How are things today in your corner of the mycoverse, Jeff? Muchas gracias para tener me into podcast. It's great to be here. I, I really appreciate it, Dennis. 0:46 It's, it's, uh, g- wonderful to talk to you, wonderful to talk to somebody who also is knowledgeable about fungi, so this is gonna be fun. 0:54 Well, you're in good company because the audience also is very passionate about fungi, and that's why they've all stuck with me so far, so thank you all for listening in today. 1:02 We're gonna unpack some of the extraordinary and inspiring mycopreneurial career of Jeff today. 1:08 But before we get to the present moment and the international trade deals and the accolades and all that, I've gotta ask you, Jeff, what first got you into mushrooms, and did you immediately know that this was your life calling, or did that unfold over an unforeseen series of events? 1:25 Okay. I don't tell this story to everybody. [laughs] I was in, in Phoenix, Arizona, in high school in the early '60s. In 1964, a friend of mine went to Mexico to Mexico City to University of the Americas. 1:39 Oh, man, I was so jealous. I wanted so badly to go down there. I was studying Spanish in high school. Oh. He comes back after that, and he has a story about eating magic mushrooms. 1:54 [laughs] And I'm like, "What? That is amazing." A- and that just stuck with me, and I was just like, wow, and, and believe it or not, in 1964, 2:08 we were just starting to learn about smoking a little pot a- and, and it was a very small group. [laughs] It was very secret, secret society. And so, 2:22 you know, that when I went on to university, of course we're talking about the '60s. So Dennis, come on. What do you do? It's the '60s. So we're not drinking as much. 2:33 We are, are toking more, and things like mushrooms and other psychoactives are a big part of that. So that's kind of where it all began, and then of course, look, I, I, I grew up in the Pacific Northwest. 2:49 It's, it's the perfect climate for mushrooms, right? So they were around me and, and because of that, we could get out and wild mushrooming, and I, I took a mycology course at the university while I was there. 3:02 I studied anthropology. My whole thing with anthropology was mushroom-focused, um, mushrooms used for medicinal purposes, mushrooms used in shamanic rites. 3:15 So you know, it was kind of that whole period that formed my life going forward. 3:21 Sure, and I have a similar background in that it was psychoactive fungi and psilocybin mushrooms that really sucked me into the whole mushroom universe, as I think it is for a lot of people, 'cause growing up in San Diego, mushrooms were button mushrooms that come on your pizza and you pick 'em off or, you know, they're at the salad bar and they're all slimy. 3:39 And then I went to University of San Francisco, so kind of had the legacy of the Haight Street days and all that, and USF is right next to Golden Gate Park and the Haight. 3:47 I had some prior experience with limited amounts of magic mushrooms before that, but that blew the floodgates open and I started seeing all the overlap between the arts and the culture and the tech, and it just, it kinda fused everything for me, and that's launched a lifelong journey of inquiry that I'm very fortunate to still be on today. 4:04 So you got into mushrooms through the '60s, and by the way, I think '64 was when The Beatles may have released their debut LP and broke in America around then, so the number of pot smokers decidedly started to grow after that, I believe. 4:16 But what got you into cultivating? After university was 1971, and I, I decided that I wanted to go to Mexico and pursue my mushroom, uh, interest. 4:31 So I, I, I moved to, to, uh, Mexico and I, I lived in Oaxaca for a year and a half, and during that period I was up in the, in the mountains, uh, Huautla and other places because I, I knew all these places because I had read all of the information from Gordon Wasson. 4:47 In fact, you know, Gordon Wasson, uh, as you know, he and his wife were the ones that came down to Mexico in the '50s and actually rediscovered the mushrooms growing up in the mountains of, uh, of Oaxaca. 5:02 A- and so I knew about all those places. I knew about his, his journey down here. 5:07 I was very familiar with all that, so I was just down there kind of following that track a- and, but when I got back from Mexico, I mean, look, I, I was in- living in Mexico on $5 a day at most. [laughs] It was... 5:20 I was hitchhiking all around, and it was just a wonderful time, very free and easy, and I, I love Mexico. I love the people down here. They're so friendly. 5:29 You know, you get picked up hitchhiking by all sorts of different people. They're stopping somewhere. They're buying you lunch, a dinner, you name it. It, it's just, it was really a wonderful time. 5:37 But you get back, and I'm like, "I've got a degree in anthropology. What am I gonna do with it?" And, and so I go to my mycology professor at the University of Washington and I ask, I say, "You know what? 5:47 I, I've been reading about growing mushrooms. It, it would be really great. What do you think?" And he goes, "Hey." He said, "There's a mushroom farm 60 miles down the road in Olympia, Washington. I, I know the owner." 5:58 He says, "Go down there. Uh, uh, good chance you can get a job." I went down, I applied for the job, I got the job. I was there for the next 10 years on a very large agaricus farm. 6:15 Now, now look, agaricus, as you know, is the button mushroom. We were growing 2 million pounds a year. But we had a Japanese scientist there. Or the Japanese scientist, Dr. Uriyama, he was growing shiitake. 6:28 He was growing enokitake, and he was growing oyster mushroom. And, and i- in my capacity there as a production manager, at a certain point I was working with him on these project. 6:40 So I got to learn about how to grow other species of mushrooms. I was eating fresh shiitake in the '70s. Can you imagine? 6:51 [laughs] So, so for me it was, like, an amazing time, and that really kicked off my whole career as a mushroom grower. 7:01 I, I mean, look, when you're h- on a large scale mushroom farm, uh, you literally are living with mushrooms. 7:10 And we had, uh, probably about 40 different rooms in every stage of production, because it's on a cropping cycle, 90-day cropping cycle. So let's just say five houses get dumped, five new houses get put in. 90-day cycle. 7:27 A- and, and you know what's interesting about mushroom growing is mushrooms do not sleep. [laughs] You know, it's like a plant. A plant doesn't stop growing. Uh, mushrooms don't sleep. They don't stop growing. 7:41 You have to be there every single day of the year to harvest the mushrooms. 7:47 Because if you don't, you get a whole day's worth of mushrooms, tens of thousands of pounds, that mature, and now you've got a second instead of a first. 7:59 So this is really something about mushroom growing that a lot of people don't understand. And, you know, how many people maybe you could ask... I, I ask people all the time, "Well, have you ever been to a mushroom farm?" 8:11 I don't know, one out of 100 has said yes. Nobody knows or has been to a mushroom farm, unless maybe they live in Kennett Square, Pennsylvania or something like that, where it's a huge, massive industry. 8:24 But otherwise, you just drive right by because the mushrooms are all being grown indoors in large warehouses that are climate controlled a- and keep everything at an optimum temperature so that you're getting the maximum yield. 8:40 So at any rate, for me, that was, uh, a major period in my life. And the '70s, God, Dennis, and the '70s was such an exciting time for mushrooms. 8:52 There were mushroom conferences that we were, we were creating and, um, where we would have, uh, people like Wasson would be at some of these. Richard Evans Schultes would be at some of these. Uh, Andrew Weil. 9:05 At one of these conferences, there was actually Albert Hofmann was there. So the '70s was an amazing time. A- and the other part of the '70s was, you know, in the '60s there was a, a man named Carlos Castaneda. 9:21 He wrote a bunch of books about Don Juan, a Yaqui, uh, shaman. A- and that, everybody was just like, "Oh my God, I, I wanna go and find my own Don Juan." 9:32 [laughs] So, so that's why a lot of people went to Mexico looking for their Don Juan. Just like today, a lot of people go to the Amazon looking for their shaman to take you on this, this vision quest. 9:48 But one of the things that happened was that during the '70s, we realized that psilocybe mushrooms actually grew in North America, too, as well as worldwide. 10:01 So coming back to the Pacific Northwest, we have Psilocybe semilanceata. We learn about Psilocybe cyanescens, Baeocystis, all of these local species. 10:15 During that period, you had hundreds of people out in the pastures in the Pacific Northwest, head down, looking for Psilocybe semilanceata. It was such an interesting time. 10:30 And, and so, so that was kind of like instead of having to go to Mexico looking for mushrooms, no, y- they were right in your backyard. 10:40 You know, the story you're telling about going down to Oaxaca, I can really relate to that in that in 2010, I went on a road trip with some college friends. I was... 10:50 It was after my junior year of college at USF, and we drove from Oaxaca to Costa Rica. 10:56 Well, I was waiting for them for a few days in Oaxaca before they got there, and by the time they came, I realized, "Hey, we're only a colectivo ride or, like, a minibus ride away from Maria Sabina's village, from Huautla de Jimenez." 11:11 And I think by that point, the fervor around Huautla had died down because nobody seemed to have it on the map, uh, at least from what I could tell. 11:20 So we jumped in a colectivo, went up to the mountain town, and just started asking questions. And sure enough, someone jumped in the car and said, "I'll take you to the house, the family house." 11:29 And I haven't shared this story yet on the podcast. So we rolled up to the house, just said, "Hey, we're, we're here. How's everything going with all y'all?" They were really cool. 11:37 Uh, Filo, her nephew, I believe, maybe it's her son, invited us to stay for dinner, and then he invited us to stay for the night. 11:44 So we spent two nights at the Sabina household with her surviving family, and I got to be in that small room where she was conducting the veladas and the ceremonies. 11:53 And I saw the original Life magazine cover with her on it, or with Wasson, that they had propped up. 11:59 And they actually invited me to be part of a velada, part of a ceremony And funny enough, you know, I had never had mushrooms and honey up until that point, and mostly I'd had dried mushrooms, so I didn't quite know what to expect. 12:10 But they had the copal incense, and they were... You know, her nephew was chanting. And about two or three hours went by. A long time went by, and nothing happened. 12:20 Pretty much we all decided, "I guess we didn't take enough. It didn't work. We're gonna go back to our room where we're sleeping." And so we hung out. 12:27 In the middle of the night, I got awoken in a full-on magnificent visionary state, and it lasted the entire night. And I had just profound visionary activity. 12:39 And then in the morning [laughs], the other guys were like, "Man, I can't believe those mushrooms didn't work." 12:43 And I was [laughs] I was sitting there like, "Yeah, yeah, they, they didn't work," but it was so awesome because, uh... You know, and I've had this conversation with other folks on the podcast. 12:51 Like, we, we really don't know how these things work because that doesn't make sense. 12:54 It was about a seven-hour delayed e- uh, effect that it had on me, as opposed to the traditional you eat mushrooms and then an hour later you're on the way up, and then you peak. 13:03 It was a totally different timeline, and I just have a great reverence for that mystery and for all of what that family did and what they're continuing to do in Huautla. So I just wanted to share that story. 13:13 That is so interesting because, uh, I was back in Huautla in, I think it was 2002 or 2003. And, uh, of course, Maria Sabina, I think she died in, in the '90s or something like that. 13:26 A- and she was over 90 years old, which was really interesting when you think of here's a woman who took very large amounts of mushrooms most of her life. 13:36 A- and obviously, who knows, maybe it was something that prolonged her life because, I mean, look, in those mountains, the conditions, the living conditions there are not good. Hygiene is not good. 13:47 Uh, the fact that you can live to be 90 and living in those mountains is really pretty amazing. But, but we were there in 2002, my, my wife and I, and we knew about a woman that, who was there that was a, uh, curandera. 14:03 Her name was Doña Julieta, and we had a velada with her a- and it was just quite, uh, amazing. And, and the... She had an altar set up that was just absolutely full of fresh cut flowers. 14:20 She had icons on there and then, of course, uh, candlelight and things like that. It was really quite a, uh, a very special night for us. But, but, you know, the fact that you actually went up there. 14:33 And, and here is what kind of happened too, and I don't know how many people are actually aware of this, but in the 1960s, 14:46 so many people had gone up to Huautla and, and were wandering around in Huautla, uh, very high on mushrooms. So many people were doing that that they actually closed it off, Dennis. 15:04 They put soldiers on all the entrances, uh, down below Huautla, because it was a long, uh, trip back up into the mountains to get there. 15:14 They put soldiers there to keep people out, and they went in to the Huautla area, and they collected every single gringo that was there, uh, pulled them out, and deported them. 15:28 And Huautla was then closed off to the general public or especially to foreigners for a period of maybe 15 years or so. Literally soldiers out on the roads going in. 15:46 And so when we were back there in 2002, by that time, they're actually having mushroom festivals in Huautla. And Maria Sabina is now, uh, like the patron saint and very famous. She's gone, but very famous. 16:04 And there was nothing more than three Mexican hippies in town, in town. Everybody else in the world had completely forgotten about it. A- and, and 16:19 in my mind, that was very, a very positive thing because literally in the late '60s, it just got completely overrun with very disrespectful people, unfortunately. 16:33 A- and the other thing that happens anthropologically in these situations is when people come in like that, 16:40 all of a sudden they're coming in with money, and the mushrooms become a saleable commodity, which, uh, it hurts the whole cultural aspect of it and also sets up this dynamic where some people are getting wealthy on the basis of selling mushrooms to foreigners. 17:00 So, so it was not a very good situation ultimately what happened there. 17:07 But we were sort of reaching a point, uh, in our culture in the North where, uh, communication was such that this information was out, and especially after the 1957, uh, Life magazine article. 17:21 Many people haven't seen that amazing article. 17:25 I love to talk about it because, uh, in that article or on the cover of Life magazine, which was basically a coffee table magazine with human interest stories, on the cover of it, they had, they had a series called Great Adventures, and it was Great Adventures Three or Four or something, "Mushrooms that Cause Visions [laughs] Discovered in Mexico." 17:51 And, and it was like, "Isn't this interesting?" [laughs] Can you imagine something like that being published in the '70s? No, no. It would've been, "Mushrooms that Cause Visions Creating Havoc in Some Place Somewhere." 18:09 [laughs] But no, this was like- Isn't that interesting? And I'm just like, "Man, was that ever an innocent time." Sure. I was surprised when I went up, I didn't see a single other gringo or a single hippie. 18:23 I think I must have hit it after the fervor died down. 'Cause, uh, we went up there and I didn't see another traveler, and they seemed very happy to welcome us. 18:33 And they asked us for $3 a night to stay in Maria Sabina's room, where she used to stay. So I'll... 18:39 That's a story I'll always treasure, and, uh, never told it on the podcast before, and I don't even love to go into details just 'cause it was so personally meaningful and I'm, I'm holding onto it. 18:48 But I wanna shift gears a bit because I love talking mushrooms and travel. 18:52 It's one of my favorite intersections, and I've been very fortunate to travel all over the planet and learn a lot about different people working with mushrooms in different capacities. 19:03 I grew up hosting exchange students from all over the planet, many from the former Soviet Union, you know, from Ukraine, from Poland, uh, microphilic cultures. We had students from Brazil. 19:14 So that gave, gave me an opportunity to travel later and stay with some of these families. And, you know, the more I've traveled, the more... 19:22 Well, the more I see, the less I know, but I learn more about fungi and how people use them. 19:26 So the first time, and only time, I've been to China was in 2006 for three weeks, and I had a magnificent eye-opening experience there. We were in, uh, Beijing. I rode the toboggan down from the Great Wall. Xi'an. 19:40 Kind of like pretty typical tourist route. We went to Lijiang and Yangshuo, which were two of my favorites, 'cause they were gorgeous. Lijiang is an amazing place. 19:50 I mean, the foothills of Tibet, this old ancient village there, uh, with this, this small creek running through the middle of it, and cobblestones and stone houses. Lijiang is a favorite place of mine, too. 20:04 I have this image seared into my mind walking through those cobblestone streets you mentioned near the riverfront in Lijiang, and I saw what later I construed to be a reishi mushroom vendor who had a, a, a bundle on his back, and it looked like these big conks of reishi mushrooms. 20:21 And it just was this image that was very an- anachronistic. Like, it didn't seem to belong to the 21st century. It seemed to be something from, you know, 100 or 200 years ago or more. 20:33 And I remember trying to chase this guy down, because at that point in my life, I had tried psilocybin mushrooms once and had an extraordinary experience, so I was like, "They know something here. 20:43 That guy's got a bunch of mushrooms." I didn't know they were reishi at the time, but I could identify that there was something going on. 20:49 And I, I lost him in the hustle and the bustle, but that image is seared into my mind. 20:53 And years later, I've come to learn how advanced the Chinese mushroom culture is, and especially in comparison to the West in terms of the, the fact that it's my understanding that there are preschool through PhD level fungi-centric education opportunities available. 21:11 You can buy cordyceps in markets that are grown on different substrates, so on and so forth. There's this historic legacy, as you're well aware, and it's very commonly accepted and used by people in China. 21:23 And now the West is starting, and other countries, we've got listeners in Australia, India, Europe, shout out to all of you, people are starting to catch up with this. 21:32 So I'm curious, you first got to China, what are some of the impressions you first had when you went over there, and how have those impressions changed after cultivating mushrooms and living in China? 21:42 My first trip to China was in 1989, and that was for an international congress on mushroom science. 21:50 And one of the amazing things about China with th- that population, they have hundreds and hundreds of mushroom scientists. So all through the '90s, I traveled extensively in China a- and I went to conferences. 22:05 I visited research institutes. I visited farms that were growing mushrooms. I visited processors. And, you know, think about this for a second. 22:15 In the United States, we have one university in the United States that has a department for, uh, mushroom cultivation, uh, uh, a- and kind of sort of, uh, mushroom, nutritional aspects of mushrooms and all. 22:27 That's Penn State University because of the large mushroom industry they have there. Back in the '70s when I was growing mushrooms commercially, they had maybe 12 or 15 scientists there working in that field. 22:40 Um, today they have maybe two or three scientists at Penn State, whereas in China they've got, I mean, not just universities, but these research stations all over China. 22:55 They have hundreds of scientists working on mushroom cultivation. And so from 1989 through today, China went from producing approximately, let's just say 23:13 30% of the world's mushrooms in 1989. Today they produce 85% of the world's cultivated mushrooms. Think about that for a second. 85%. 23:27 So, so, so it was so rich, and that's one of the reasons that I, I went there was because look, if you're, if you're interested in medicinal mushrooms, that's where they've been used for thousands of years, in China in traditional Chinese medicine. 23:43 So that's where the reservoir of information was, including traditional Chinese practitioners, including, uh, mushroom farmers, mushroom scientists. 23:53 All of the different, uh, um, conferences I went to, I met so many interesting people, and it took me, um, all, to all parts of China. Like, we were talking about Lijiang, which is in Yunnan Province. 24:06 Yunnan Province had a, a great research station there, and also they harvest Tons and tons and tons of wild mushrooms every year that they ship out all over the world. So it's a center of wild mushrooming. 24:23 That was, that was interesting to me. But, you know, here, here's what's, what I learned as a mushroom grower in the United States at the mushroom farm. 24:34 Uh, when you're growing mushrooms, remember, every mushroom you've ever eaten has been harvested by hand. [laughs] A lot of people don't know that. There, there's... 24:45 Okay, today they've got a couple of mechanical harvesting machines in Europe, but this is like something for a very specific type of system. Every mushroom you've ever eaten in the United States has been picked by hand. 24:59 That means you have an army of harvesters that have to go into those houses every single day to harvest those mushrooms. 25:07 So growing mushrooms in the United States or Canada, you can do that and you can make a profit selling those fresh. But, [laughs] supplements are dried powders. 25:22 As you know, a mushroom is 90%-plus water, like most vegetables. You dry out that shiitake that you've been getting, let's just say, $5 a pound for, now you have to get $50 a pound for that same shiitake. 25:39 The economics do not work in North America for growing mushrooms and putting them into the supplement market. 25:49 Absolutely you cannot do it, and there are no mushrooms grown in the United States that are being used as supplements, with the exception of some small herbalist that's making tinctures for her clients or for a small, uh, group of people, and she can... 26:08 She makes it herself, so she can charge a reasonable price retail. She can buy from a local small producer or something. Otherwise, the economics don't work. So I realized that, um, early on. 26:21 So when I went to China, one of the issues was I want to find mushroom producers, because I started my business in 1989, uh, selling medicinal mushrooms into the supplement industry. 26:35 No company in the United States had mushrooms in their supplement line. You know, echinacea and ginseng and ginkgo, all of those different herbal products out there, nobody was selling, um, medicinal mushrooms. 26:50 So, so for me, it was kind of like, okay, A, I'm gonna have to go to China, grow my mushrooms there, and process them and bring them over, and B, I've got to educate a lot of companies [laughs] as well as a lot of people out there that mushrooms have functional benefits, uh, as well as really good nutritional benefits. 27:14 And, and yes, let me tell you, I've seen changes in China that are monumental. Because when I was first there, it was totally into the teardown stage. 27:28 Everything was being torn down and rebuilt and as a brand-new building, a brand-new factory. Uh, today they have freeways better than anything we've got. 27:40 Today in China, I ride around on trains, high-speed rail going 300 kilometers an hour, brand-new, comfortable trains. It's night and day. 27:54 So, so the '90s was really a, a period of organiz- organizing production and, and finding partners that could organize, um, producing mushrooms for me, finding a, a good processor that could p- process all of those mushrooms into an extract powder. 28:16 I'm not gonna ship fresh mushrooms or even dried mushrooms back to North America. No, we process it into extracts. 28:23 And one, you know, one of the things too is since 1992 my company's been organic cert- organically certified. I believe in that. 28:32 So in 1997, I took OCIA, one of the largest certifiers in the US, to China with me, and we had the very first organic certification workshop for mushrooms in China, 1997. So 28:49 yeah, China, it, it's a big part of it. A- and why not? I, I mean, look, it... Do you know that when you... when it comes to, like, bringing a mushroom into cultivation, 29:01 Dennis, it's a huge deal to bring a, a new mushroom into cultivation. Oh, yeah, sure, you can maybe grow a lot of mushrooms in culture and, and maybe you'll get a few mushrooms to grow on something. 29:14 But to actually develop a cultivar and to then be able to produce that commercially on a vast scale, and they just recently did that with cordyceps militaris. 29:30 God, what an amazing feat that is. 29:33 And that just, to me, demonstrates the intelligence, the, the number of people working in the field, and the fact that they are so organized that they can take this from pilot scale up to producing tons and tons of this mushroom every year. 29:53 It's fascinating. And specifically with the cordyceps, that's so timely. 29:57 We've had a micropreneur on the podcast by the name of Hamilton Pevic who is married into a Nepali family and went on a wild cordyceps hunt for a couple weeks with his brother-in-law. 30:07 So we got into the economics and the dynamics of the wild cordyceps trade, and how it's putting a lot of strain on the environment because people are figuring out you can make enough money for the whole year By going out and finding a couple of these caterpillar fungus per day. 30:23 And apparently, China now has the technology, from what I understand, to cultivate cordyceps sinensis, and they're mixing in cultivated cordyceps sinensis with the wild trade to keep the price high. 30:36 But I think that's very interesting, 'cause it has the intersection of sort of geopolitics and socioeconomics and marginalized communities, et cetera. 30:43 But yes, the short answer, I suppose, to relieving the strain on over-harvesting is just more cultivation. Oh, you know, it absolutely is. 30:51 And look, now the other side of this too, which is a, a, a negative for me, is that when you have, uh, something like the wild cordyceps sinensis, and all of a sudden the demand grows and the price grows with it, then you have not only tremendous h- uh, pressure on harvesting this, but you also have issues of whose territory is this. 31:18 And I don't know if you're aware of it, but about 10 years ago, a group of locals went out and challenged some interlopers coming in to, to harvest cordyceps in their area, and actually six people were killed. 31:36 So, so a- a- and the other side of that that I don't like is that it distorts the local economy. 31:44 I don't believe that it's a good thing that people can go out, wildcraft and get a lot of money for wildcrafting, because ultimately all that does is drive those wild cordyceps to the point where there's fewer and fewer and fewer a- and, and, um, ultimately, uh, to me, th- that is just a issue of either... 32:09 Li- like in, in, uh, France, where this same thing happened to the Périgord truffle, where they were-- there was 200 tons coming out of there in the late 1800s and 1900s. 32:22 Today there are nine tons of, of wild plus commercial from commercial tree farms to grow it. So you can put so much pressure on there that the actual amount coming out becomes really low. 32:37 And that's why for me, I favor cultivation. 32:40 Look, cultivation of mushrooms is one of the most amazing ways to convert waste agricultural products and resources into a high-quality food and break down those lignocellulosic materials into something that actually can be put into the soil, either as something for soil structure or also amendment of the soil with, with certain nutrients. 33:11 So mushroom growing is a wonderful thing a- and the fact now that we can grow cordyceps militaris, which has been used interchangeably with sinensi- sinensis for those people that don't know it, is, is actually in, in China called caterpillar fungus, because you actually have the caterpillar still attached to the cordyceps and that the two together are part of the product. 33:38 Whereas with cordyceps militaris, we have simply the mushroom, no insect involved. I tried to introduce cordyceps sinensis to the market in the United States in 1991. You know what companies told me, Dennis? 33:53 [laughs] They said, "Oh, sorry, our customers are not gonna eat caterpillars. [laughs] A- and not only that, they're vegetarian." [laughs] How things change, how quickly they change. 34:08 And you know, I'd love to shift gears to talking about something we briefly brought up earlier, which is about quality control. 34:14 Because as the West, as the United States and Europe, Australia, et cetera, starts to catch fungi fever and mushroom mania, there's a flood of new products and supplements coming to the market. 34:28 And in my understanding, there's no agreed-upon set of standards. Maybe there are, but they're certainly not publicized or published on a lot of these products. 34:37 And I've seen an article, which I'll try to link to the episode if I find it, about random testing in supermarkets of different functional mushroom products that didn't actually have the active compounds they were claiming they had in them. 34:49 So it's just sort of this gold rush that a lot of people are cashing in on. 34:53 And as a example or an illustration of this narrative and kind of the clashes is the whole fruiting body versus mycelium narrative that a lot of people are, are peddling different angles to it. 35:03 I'm sure you know a lot more about that than myself and a lot of our listeners, but what I'm curious about is it's my understanding that Nammex was instrumental in introducing a set of standards and quality control in order to be able to verify the efficacy and the potency of the compounds in your extract. 35:22 So can you tell us a little bit about the quality control and some of the standards that are in place, and if this is something that might be universally adopted in the US, or is that too much to wish for? 35:33 In, in 2015, I did a, a study a- and in that study I had 95 samples a- and there were dried mushrooms, there were, uh, some of our mushroom extracts, and then I went out on the internet and I bought 40 35:51 retail products that were manufactured, um, and they were actually mycelium products that were grown on grain. 36:01 Now, now y- at that time, a lot of people didn't understand that whole aspect of it a- a- and what it is is that, 36:10 like I was saying earlier, you cannot grow mushrooms in North America and put them into the supplement market. The economics don't work. 36:19 So what happened was a lot of companies started to grow mycelium On sterilized grain. Now, in the mushroom industry, we just call that grain spawn. 36:33 What you do is you grow out mycelium, and then you put it on a carrier. Because you just can't grow out mycelium and go, "Oh, we got all this mycelium. Let's mix it into something." It doesn't work that way. 36:45 So you grow the mycelium on sterilized grain. They used to grow it on all sorts of different materials back in the 1920s, but in the 1930s, they, they figured out, "Oh, you could grow it on grain." 36:58 And so each grain, like in a gallon, maybe you got 3,000 grains. They get colonized with mycelium, which covers the grain, and now you have what we call grain spawn. 37:09 So you can, you can basically take that myceliated grain, you can mix it into your substrate, which is what we call the growing media for growing mushrooms. 37:20 You can mix it in, and every one of those grains becomes like a seed. So the mycelium will grow off that grain into the food source, which in the case of Agaricus is a compost. 37:32 Other mushrooms, it would be a sawdust type of material. So, but that's all done in a lab. It's a sterile culture situation. 37:41 Well, a lot of companies just went, "Oh, gee, well, what if I just grew mycelium on that sterilized grain? 37:49 And at the end of a grow-out period of, let's say, 30, 40 days, I just take it out of our jar or bag or whatever, I lay it out on screens, I dry it, I grind it to a powder, and now I'm gonna call that mushroom." 38:06 So grain and all, because you cannot separate the mycelium from the grain. So what, what I knew was going on out there were a lot of companies were using this process and 38:23 actually claiming that their product was mushroom. So I bought those 40 products of that type of fungal product a- and I tested them all with a test that was for beta-glucans. 38:39 Beta-glucan is the important polysaccharide that makes mushrooms medicinal. If you do not have beta-glucans, it's not a medicinal mushroom, period. It's that simple. 38:51 So this test also allowed me to see what are called alpha-glucans, which are starches. Mushrooms have no starch. Like us, mushrooms produce a small amount of glycogen as their storage carbohydrate. So here it is. 39:09 I could measure the amount of beta-glucans in my mushroom samples and in these myceliated grain samples. 39:17 Well, it turns out that mushrooms have anywhere from, uh, 25 to 60% beta-glucan and a small amount of alpha, which is either the starches or the glycogen, like 1% or 2%, something like that. 39:33 So 30 to 60 beta-glucan, uh, less than, uh, 1% or less than 5% alpha. It was the exact opposite of these myceliated grain products. 39:46 They were around 5% beta-glucan and 30 to 60% alpha-glucan, or essentially starch from all of the grain that was in those products. 40:03 So they were actually selling products that were mostly grain powder. And, and a good example of that is you're familiar with tempeh, right? 40:13 Tempeh is a real interesting product because it is cooked soybeans with fungal mycelium grown on it. So when you're eating tempeh, you're actually eating mycelium. It's very cool. 40:26 Well, [laughs] that's what these people are producing, is they're producing a tempeh-like product. Sure. 40:35 And, you know, the whole myceliated grain versus fruiting body bit, our friend Alex Dorr from Mushroom Revival has a great analogy he uses. 40:45 It's like making an apple pie, and when you buy an apple pie, you want the apples in it. 40:49 But if you're buying the myceliated grain products, it's like they put the twigs, the roots, the leaves, everything in that apple pie, and you don't necessarily want that, especially when you're talking about the medicinal benefit of a functional mushroom product. 41:02 So thank you for going into detail there. There are a lot of people, I think, who are starting to test their products because it's hopefully becoming just more in demand by the market, by people. 41:13 For example, Mushroom Revival puts the QR code to their lab testing results for their products, and I'm sure Nammex can provide all of the COAs and everything too. 41:23 But there are a lot of products when you go into the Whole Foods where we're, we're kind of confused about what we're getting here. So th- thank you for breaking that down in detail. It's very helpful. 41:32 And along those lines, talking about all the different types of mushrooms that people put in their products, right? Reishi, lion's mane, cordyceps. Those are three big ones that come to mind. Shiitake. 41:43 I was in Telluride this year at the Telluride Mushroom Festival, and the renowned Canadian mycologist Robert Rogers told us about the Antrodia mushroom. 41:54 So that's endemic to Taiwan, and it's my understanding that it's quite shrouded in secrecy at the corporate level. 42:01 I asked a buddy who works for a high-profile mushroom cultivation operation if he could get me some, and he goes, "I've got Antrodia, but I can't give a tissue culture to anyone." 42:11 So I'm curious, is that Antrodia mushroom something you've worked with before or you're familiar with in China? Antrodia is really [laughs] kind of a, an interesting fungus. 42:22 And, and, you know, from what I've seen, it, it hardly even has a real Fruiting body that you could collect. It looks more like it's just something that coats the side of these specific trees. 42:37 I- I've looked at the research on it. It, it looks pretty solid, but most of the products, uh, uh, Antrodia, because there is no real fruiting body that you can harvest, most of the Antrodia out there is mycelium. 42:53 I- I- I- I gener- you know, generally speaking, Dennis, I- I tell people, "You know, you're probably better off staying away from mycelium products" And, and I say that because I sold Cordyceps mycelium products for 15 years because back in the '90s, because the price of wild Cordyceps was going up, they developed Cordyceps, but they grew it in liquid fermentation, meaning that they could harvest pure mycelium a- and, and they sell hundreds of tons of that product in China today, and in Asia. 43:32 And once I got the ability to do better testing, I just found that the products that I, I could get of that Cordyceps mycelia, and one of the import- of the major ones called CS-4, that Cordyceps mycelia, it was just not a great product all in all. 43:50 So I- I- I... The same thing is with Antrodia. I really don't know enough about it or, you know, with the mycelium products, you're just not getting the same things you'd be getting as you would with an actual mushroom. 44:01 I'm sure you've got your hands full already with the 10 to 12 functional mushrooms that you're working with with Nammex and everything else you've got going on, and I'd love to dive into what you're working on right now for a second. 44:14 I told some people you were coming on the show, and they're like, "Man, where does Nammex go next?" 44:19 Like, you established a global mass cultivation empire and are providing all these wholesale products to different companies and set industry standards and all kinds of cool stuff, and we're super honored to have you, but where does Nammex go next? 44:35 What are you working on now? What, what can you share with us? 44:37 Well, well, you know, a- and that, that's really interesting because, you know, one of the things that I've had to do is, like, cut down the actual number of species we sell because you get to a point when... 44:47 And it's like, what's the actual difference between a maitake and a shiitake or a shiitake and a tremella? Where, where do you draw the line? 44:55 Because I've got a book called Icon- Icons of Medicinal Mushrooms, uh, from China that lists 270 medicinal mushroom species. Well, obviously you're not gonna go there. 45:05 So I- I- I, at this point in time, one of the really cool things that we are doing is we are, uh, in a development stage for producing mushroom vitamin D. 45:22 A- and for those who are unaware, mushrooms do not have much vitamin D in them, but ergosterol, the fungal sterol, much like our cholesterol, 45:34 when it is exposed to UV light, changes into vitamin D2. So we've got something that is, is, um, not a- an animal-based vitamin D, uh, and it comes strictly from mushroom. 45:52 A- and I- I'm just really stoked on that, to be moving into vitamins from mushrooms. My God, I, I just thought- think that is so cool. 46:05 The other thing that we're doing is we're, we can analyze our products for a compound called ergothioneine. Ergothioneine is, um, in fungi. 46:20 It, they are one of the categories of foods that produce high amounts. 46:24 Very few animal products or vegetable products produce high levels of ergothioneine, and it is something that has shown to be a very, very strong antioxidant. 46:34 It seems to show up in lots of parts of our body, but we don't produce it. We have to get it externally. Mushrooms are a high source of it. 46:43 So we, we actually have an ergothioneine product that we are selling right now, but that particular product that we're selling comes from yeast. It's very, very expensive. 46:54 You only take five milligrams a day, but I think it's a very important longevity supplement, and some people, uh, actually think of it as a possible vitamin. So we're looking and we're testing. 47:09 We have been testing all of our mushrooms now for, for two years for ergothioneine content so we know which ones to target. 47:18 And we're just looking at that as how we can possibly, from our actual mushrooms that we grow, um, be able to produce a little bit higher ergothioneine product where we could get to that five milligram a- amount through our mushroom extracts. 47:36 That, that, um, yeast ergothioneine that we're selling right now, I mean, God, I, I hate to say this, I think it's like 10 or $15,000 a, a kilogram. I mean, it is just insanely expensive. 47:48 So, so we're hoping to be able to produce that on a scale that will be, you know, more economical, and it'll actually be from a Basidiomycete rather than from a yeast. So, so that's another thing. 48:04 But, but the vitamin D thing, I mean, man, I'm, I'm totally stoked on that. 48:09 And the other thing that we did here recently, which I really love, is we put out a product that had, um, I believe it is 400 milligrams of our mushroom extracts, um, tw- 30 milligrams of zinc, and, um, 48:27 2,000 IUs of vitamin D. So it's actually a mushroom product with vitamin D and zinc And, and that just sort of came to my mind two years ago with the start of the whole, uh, virus. And I thought, you know what? 48:42 I, I used to take zinc all the time. I used to take vitamin D all the time. Now the information is very clear. Vitamin D is so important, especially for viral, um, um, virus effects and, and so is zinc. 48:55 And I thought, well, God, I, I'm gonna make a product for myself [laughs] and, and also put it out in our product line. And so we call it D2Z, which is vitamin D2 plus zinc, plus our mushroom extracts. 49:13 And I, I take that every day as well as I take our ergothioneine product, and, uh, I'm really keen on, on those. Awesome. Well, I'll be looking forward to trying some of that myself at some point. 49:25 And before I let you go today, there's one question I'd love to throw your way, since you've had almost 50 years of experience cultivating mushrooms and being involved in the mushroom industry, and as a micropreneur. 49:38 We've got in our audience, people at all levels. 49:41 We've got people who are selling at farmer's markets, people who are, uh, cultivating at scale, you know, people who are making mycelium leather, just all these awesome people working with fungi. 49:52 And I'd love to know if you have any parting shots of like overarching things that you've learned in your career or, uh, maybe principles that you follow that helped you to get to where you are today. 50:03 I know it's a broad question, but are there any parting shots you have for the audience of things that maybe helped you continue in such a prosperous career arc for so long? 50:14 I guess one of the things I, I, I would tell people is follow your passion. Whatever it happens to be, follow your passion. You're not gonna make a lot of money in the beginning, [laughs] 50:24 but ultimately, ultimately, no matter what people do, if they do it well enough, somebody's [laughs] gonna come along and pay you to do it. 50:32 A- and you know, if, if you're a mushroom grower, look, it's not easy because especially when you're a small scale cultivator, you are a babysitter. Not only that, y- mushrooms don't sleep. You know that. 50:46 You've got to harvest them, and you've got to get them to market. They will spoil on you. Not only that, you've got to get to scale to even be able to make more than the $2 an hour you're making now. 50:58 [laughs] So it's, it's a tough slog, but in the beginning when people are younger and, and they have the ability to do that, and maybe they've got another job or something like that, and they're very keen, man, it is so much fun. 51:14 Uh, it's just wonderful living with them, watching them grow. Um, the issue becomes ultimately, how long can I continue to make $2 [laughs] an hour? You know, because you do have to scale up to a certain point. 51:30 But again, uh, for me, look, the, the most valuable thing you have in your life is time. It's, it's your life. You can punch the clock, or you can follow your passion. Wise words. 51:43 Thank you so much, Jeff Chilton of Mammex, for joining us on the Micropreneur Podcast. Huge fans of your work, and we wish you continued good fortune and prosperity. Thank you so much, Dennis. 51:53 It's just been a, a pleasure being here talking to you. 51:56 There's so much to cover in the mushroom universe and so many micropreneurs leveraging the infinite potential of fungi to create a more ecologically balanced, inclusive, and equitable world for all of us mischievous little monkeys. 52:10 I am completely stoked that you've chosen to spend some of your hard-earned time in our little corner of the mycoverse. Hop on the Gram, say what's up, @micropreneurpodcast. That's the handle. Don't get it twisted. 52:24 We've got the full suite of social media up and running. Twitter, Micropreneur. Got the YouTubes dialed in, Micropreneur. Drop us a line. Tell your grandma and your kooky uncle. Tell your wife and your kids. 52:35 If you're a micropreneur yourself, you wanna hop on the pod, by all means, willkommen, bienvenidos, welcome. Don't be a stranger. 52:44 Let us know your thoughts on this episode, and also let us know what you want to hear in future episodes. This is a team effort. Thanks for stopping by the Micropreneur Podcast. Have a lovely day. 52:54 We'll see you back here next week. [outro music]